"l3osides a widow, Mr. Charles is survived by five sons nod thlre doughters."
OCR: "Besides a widow, Mr. Charles is survived by five sons and three daughters." The five sons are then named, William Webster Charles among them — direct evidence for the father link to Herbert Cole Charles #21726 and, through the widow, to Mary Ann Webster #21727.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"The sons are lIessrs. Leslie Thomans Charles, plumbor, Gdulburn; Anrthui Ierhert, orchardist, Gosslburn Alfred lames, lolkacksmithl, of Oberon (at prsent seriously ill wiith pnsieiumonic-inoiisnza); David Henry, orchardist, Tallong; and William Webster Charles, head plumber in the Goulburn Loe. Dept."
OCR: "Leslie Thomas Charles, plumber, Goulburn; Arthur Herbert, orchardist, Goulburn; Alfred James, blacksmith, of Oberon (at present seriously ill with pneumonic influenza); David Henry, orchardist, Tallong; and William Webster Charles, head plumber in the Goulburn Loco. Dept." The notice continues "The danughters nr Misses Ad Ethl, Edith, and Jessie Charles" — Ada Ethel, Edith and Jessie. All eight are the tree's children of #21726 and #21727; this list is the identity discriminator for the whole obituary.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionor in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home). The sons are Messrs. Leslie Thomas (Goulburn), Arthur Herbert (Goulburn), William Webster (Goulburn), Alfred James (Oberon), and David Henry (Tallong)."
OCR "missionor" = missionary. Eight children, named in full, matching the tree's surviving children of #21726 and #21727 one for one. This is what identifies the subject of the obituary as #21727 rather than another Mrs Charles.
"He was a native of Nottingham, England, and came almost direot to Goulburn, having been a resident here for nearl half-a-century."
OCR: "came almost direct to Goulburn, having been a resident here for nearly half-a-century". Corroborates the English birth and an arrival in the Goulburn district in the 1850s.
Death of Mr. E. Grenenger. Profound regret was expressed in Braidwood this (Friday) afternoon, when word was received that the death had occurred, in Goulburn, of Mr. E. Grenenger. … He was a resident of Braidwood for 50 years, and carried on the tannery business here, which he afterwards handed over to his son. Deceased, who would have been eighty years of age had he lived till Oct next, leaves four sons and five daughters, including Mrs. Turnbull (Braidwood), Sergeant Grenenger (Yass), ansd Messrs. Fred. and Les. Grenenger (Goulburn), while another son is in South Afri-ca.
Quoted as the Trove OCR stands. 'would have been eighty years of age had he lived till Oct next' is the basis for the October 1838 birth. 'another son is in South Africa' is the Wenzel Albert Grenenger who wrote home from Central Angoniland in 1903-06 and died in Nyasaland in 1950 (NSW death 999999/1950, Braidwood) — the man previously guessed in this tree to be Wenzel #82883's son Wenzel Edward B, who in fact died as an infant in 1874.