"An nld and respected resident of Goulbumn, r. florbort Cole Charles, died at his late resii dance, '\"Rosewood,\" on Saturday mosaing, at the ago of 01."
OCR is heavy: the line reads "An old and respected resident of Goulburn, Mr. Herbert Cole Charles, died at his late residence, 'Rosewood,' on Saturday morning, at the age of 61." The Saturday before this Thursday 24 April 1919 issue is 19 April; the tree records 20 April. Age 61 matches a birth of 21 April 1857 (he would have turned 62 two days after the Saturday).
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"She was the widow of the late Mr. Herbert Cole Charles, formerly of Rosewood Gardens, and was 63 years of age and a very old resident of the Goulburn district."
An age of 63 in September 1922 brackets the birth to roughly September 1858 - September 1859, which contains the recorded 28 January 1859. The birthplace recorded on this event, Picton, is not evidenced by anything I found.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"A well-known and highly-respected citzen, Mrs. H. C. Charles, died early on Monday morning at her son's residence, 10 Park-street, after a brief illness."
OCR "citzen" = citizen. Confirms the death at Goulburn already recorded. The son she was staying with is named later in the notice as "Mr. William Charles" — William Webster Charles #21724. Published Tuesday 19 September 1922, so the Monday is 18 September; the tree records 8 September and I have not altered it here.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
Since taking ill several days ago she had been residing with her son, Mr. William Charles. Her end was unexpected, as on Sunday she was able to walk about the house and was in good spirits.
Trove OCR, quoted as it stands. Read with the opening sentence already cited on this event — "died early on Monday morning at her son's residence, 10 Park-street, after a brief illness" — this fixes the death to the Monday immediately after a Sunday on which she was still walking about, in a paper published on Tuesday 19 September 1922. That Monday is 18 September 1922. The son named is William Webster Charles #21724.
"Mn. Tnoanas CnAnL.S, one of the oldest fruit. growers of Goulburn, died on Bunday morning last at the age of 82 years."
OCR is poor; the line reads "Mr. Thomas Charles, one of the oldest fruitgrowers of Goulburn, died on Sunday morning last at the age of 82 years." 7 August 1898 was a Sunday. Independent of the Goulburn Herald notice.
MARRIED, FEBRUARY 24th, at Picton, by the Rev. A. M. Tait, HERBERT COLE, second son of THOMAS CHARLES of Goulburn, to MARY, only daugh- ter of the late DAVID WEBSTER.
Family Notices column, Goulburn Evening Penny Post, Thursday 17 March 1881 p.3, published three weeks after the ceremony. Names both spouses' fathers (confirming Herbert as Thomas Charles's second son, and Mary as the late David Webster's only daughter) and gives the exact ceremony date and place, settling the DB's previous uncited 'Condobolin' in favour of Picton. PDF fetched from Trove's rendition endpoint and uploaded as media 363.
"He was very successful as a fruit. grower, and his sons, MIessrs. H. 0., J. T., and R. H. Charles, are amongst our leading orbchardists and horticulturilsts."
OCR: "fruitgrower" and "Messrs. H. C., J. F., and R. H. Charles ... leading orchardists and horticulturists".
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"David Henry, orchardist, Tallong; and William Webster Charles, head plumber in the Goulburn Loe. Dept. All are manrried - with the excoptisis of Mr. W. WV. Charles."
OCR: "head plumber in the Goulburn Loco. Dept. All are married — with the exception of Mr. W. W. Charles." From his father's obituary. He was still unmarried in April 1919, consistent with the 1921 marriage recorded in the tree.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
OCR of 'Leslie Thomas Charles, plumber, Goulburn'. Identified via the 5-son/3-daughter sibling-list discriminator already established on this article's existing citations on this family (49483, 49497) — matches the tree's complete set of #21726/#21727's 11 children one-for-one. No prior OCCU/RESI event existed on this person.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
OCR of 'Arthur Herbert, orchardist, Goulburn'. Same 5-son/3-daughter sibling-list discriminator as this article's existing citations on this family. No prior OCCU event existed on this person (only an uncited 1930 RESI, left untouched).
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
Alfred lames, lolkacksmithl, of Oberon (at prsent seriously ill wiith pnsieiumonic-inoiisnza)
OCR of 'Alfred James, blacksmith, of Oberon (at present seriously ill with pneumonic influenza)'. Same 5-son/3-daughter sibling-list discriminator as this article's existing citations on this family; independently corroborated by the mother's 1922 obituary naming 'Alfred James (Oberon)' among the same five sons.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
Same 5-son/3-daughter sibling-list discriminator as this article's existing citations on this family; independently corroborated by the mother's 1922 obituary's entry 'David Henry (Tallong)'. Tallong has no place row; omitted per the never-invent-a-place rule.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionor in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home).
OCR of 'The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionary in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home)'. Identified via the 3-daughter/5-son sibling list already grounding this article's existing citation on this family (49489).
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
This danughters nr Misses Ad Ethl, Edith, and Jessie Charles. The first-nimed is a missionary in India
OCR of 'The daughters are Misses Ada Ethel, Edith and Jessie Charles. The first-named is a missionary in India'. Independent corroboration from the father's own obituary 2.5 years earlier.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionor in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home).
OCR of 'The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionary in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home)'. Same 3-daughter/5-son sibling-list discriminator as the family's other Sept-1922-obituary facts in this pass.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
OCR of 'the latter two reside at home', following that obituary's naming of 'Misses Ad[a] Eth[e]l, Edith, and Jessie Charles' — 'the latter two' are Edith and Jessie. Independent corroboration she was already at the family home by April 1919.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
A well-known and highly-respected citzen, Mrs. H. C. Charles, died early on Monday morning at her son's residence, 10 Park-street, after a brief illness.
The same obituary later names this son as 'Mr. William Charles' and lists 'William Webster (Goulburn)' among the five sons — the identical discriminator already recorded on this person's own citation 49487 (currently attached only to his mother's DEAT event). '10 Park-street' has no place row and is named in the event summary only.
A pretty wedding was solemnised at the Bourke-street Baptist Church on Wednesday evening, when Alice Mary, eldest daughter of Mr. aud Mrs. H. E. Trueman, of Bourke-street, Goulburn, was married to Phillip, second son of Mr. and Mrs. John Kidd, of Armidale. The Rev. C. T. Bryant performed the ceremony
OCR as printed ('aud' = and). Published Thursday 25 March 1915, so 'Wednesday evening' = 24 March 1915. The report continues: bridesmaids Miss Trueman (sister of the bride) and Miss Kidd; 'Mr. A. J. Charles was best man' (Alfred James Charles #21736, whose brother William Webster Charles married the bride's sister Lillian in 1921); 'Mr. and Mrs. Kidd will reside at Leeton.' The Sunday Times (Sydney) 28 Mar 1915 p.5 (Trove 120809043) carries the same report.
Deceased, who would have been eighty years of age had he lived till Oct. next, leaves four sons and five daughters
Quoted as the Trove OCR stands; read again this session. This sentence is the whole basis for the month on his birth date: eighty in October 1918 gives October 1838, which is the year the German compilation gives independently. The citation was on the person and not on the birth event it dates; this puts it where it belongs.
"He leaves four sons and two daughters, one of his sons being in the railway service, and residing at Young."
A second masthead, independent of the Goulburn Herald, giving the same count: four sons and two daughters, one son in the railway service at Young. Trove OCR retrieved 2026-08-29.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"l3osides a widow, Mr. Charles is survived by five sons nod thlre doughters."
OCR: "Besides a widow, Mr. Charles is survived by five sons and three daughters." The five sons are then named, William Webster Charles among them — direct evidence for the father link to Herbert Cole Charles #21726 and, through the widow, to Mary Ann Webster #21727.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1919-04-24 · Page 4 · Article OBITUARY. MR. HERBERT C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 98911605Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"The sons are lIessrs. Leslie Thomans Charles, plumbor, Gdulburn; Anrthui Ierhert, orchardist, Gosslburn Alfred lames, lolkacksmithl, of Oberon (at prsent seriously ill wiith pnsieiumonic-inoiisnza); David Henry, orchardist, Tallong; and William Webster Charles, head plumber in the Goulburn Loe. Dept."
OCR: "Leslie Thomas Charles, plumber, Goulburn; Arthur Herbert, orchardist, Goulburn; Alfred James, blacksmith, of Oberon (at present seriously ill with pneumonic influenza); David Henry, orchardist, Tallong; and William Webster Charles, head plumber in the Goulburn Loco. Dept." The notice continues "The danughters nr Misses Ad Ethl, Edith, and Jessie Charles" — Ada Ethel, Edith and Jessie. All eight are the tree's children of #21726 and #21727; this list is the identity discriminator for the whole obituary.
🗞️Goulburn Evening Penny PostDate 1922-09-19 · Page 2 · Article OBITUARY. MRS. H. C. CHARLES. · Trove Id 99205154Secondary
Goulburn Evening Penny Post · Goulburn, New South Wales, Australia · other
"The daughters are Miss Ada Ethel Charles (missionor in India), and Misses Edith Mary and Jessie Elizabeth (both at home). The sons are Messrs. Leslie Thomas (Goulburn), Arthur Herbert (Goulburn), William Webster (Goulburn), Alfred James (Oberon), and David Henry (Tallong)."
OCR "missionor" = missionary. Eight children, named in full, matching the tree's surviving children of #21726 and #21727 one for one. This is what identifies the subject of the obituary as #21727 rather than another Mrs Charles.
"He was a native of Nottingham, England, and came almost direot to Goulburn, having been a resident here for nearl half-a-century."
OCR: "came almost direct to Goulburn, having been a resident here for nearly half-a-century". Corroborates the English birth and an arrival in the Goulburn district in the 1850s.
Death of Mr. E. Grenenger. Profound regret was expressed in Braidwood this (Friday) afternoon, when word was received that the death had occurred, in Goulburn, of Mr. E. Grenenger. … He was a resident of Braidwood for 50 years, and carried on the tannery business here, which he afterwards handed over to his son. Deceased, who would have been eighty years of age had he lived till Oct next, leaves four sons and five daughters, including Mrs. Turnbull (Braidwood), Sergeant Grenenger (Yass), ansd Messrs. Fred. and Les. Grenenger (Goulburn), while another son is in South Afri-ca.
Quoted as the Trove OCR stands. 'would have been eighty years of age had he lived till Oct next' is the basis for the October 1838 birth. 'another son is in South Africa' is the Wenzel Albert Grenenger who wrote home from Central Angoniland in 1903-06 and died in Nyasaland in 1950 (NSW death 999999/1950, Braidwood) — the man previously guessed in this tree to be Wenzel #82883's son Wenzel Edward B, who in fact died as an infant in 1874.